An innovative Depression-era map of American retail markets
[After John E. Brennan] / American Map Company, URBAN MARKETS AND RETAIL SALES. New York: Outdoor Advertising Incorporated, ca 1939.
42”h x 61 ½”w at neat line plus margins. Backed with cloth and mounted on dowels, as issued. Minor creasing and soiling, small chip lifting in title, small hole in western Pennsylvania. Still, about very good for such a large wall map.
$3,000.00
In stock
A very rare thematic map highlighting the major consumer markets of the United States, reflecting the revolutionary impact of the automobile on marketing, and nice evidence of the American economy’s continued capacity for innovation even in the depths of the Depression.
Background
Prior to the advent of the mass-marketed automobile, advertising was primarily a matter of placement of ads in newspapers and magazines, and of poster displays in public spaces. With the spread of automotive transportation into the American middle class, an entirely new advertising medium emerged: the roadside billboard. Large, designed to present simple messages in the most eye-catching manner possible, and by nature intrusive on the visual fields of drivers and passengers alike, billboards quickly spread over the American landscape.
Like most emerging industries, the billboard marketplace seems to have been highly fragmented, highly local, and—I assume—highly inefficient. To address this issue, in 1931 players in the industry banded together to form Outdoor Advertising Incorporated (OAI), which seems to have been an agency for marketing billboards to large companies and the ad agencies representing them.
“Practically the entire industry has joined together so that Outdoor Advertising campaigns can be properly planned and presented to America’s industries. The result is an organization to be known as Outdoor Advertising Incorporated. This company will act as the industry’s representative. It is their best effort to improve the merchandising possibilities of their medium.” (Harold Eves, “The “Outdoor” Industry Looks Ahead”, Advertising Outdoors, vol. 2 no. 7 (July 1931), p. 5)
Best as I can tell, OAI was a for-profit venture providing the billboard industry with a wide range of marketing, design, production, research, and consulting services. (“Outdoor Advertising Incorporated and How It Will Operate”, Advertising Outdoors, vol. 2 no. 7 (July 1931), pp. 11-13, 45-46, accessed online Apr. 2025)
The map
Around 1939 the organization published this massive map to illustrate the key findings of an OAI study, also titled “Urban Markets and Retail Sales”.
“A most elaborate study has recently been completed by [OAI] under the direction of John E. Brennan [a researcher specializing in assessing the effectiveness of billboard advertising, fl. 1947-1980]. It is a study of “Urban Markets and Retail Sales” and represents a new approach to market evaluation. This study presents retail sales figures drawn from the Census of Retail Distribution of the U.S. Department of Commerce, 1935 edition, grouped according to “masses of people” rather than any particular political unit…. The purpose of the study is to answer the demand for a more flexible and more practical method of market appraisal as an aid to selective and profitable selling. One interesting feature of the maps presented is the fact that they are plotted against the highway pattern of the state.” (Ferdinand C. Wheeler, “Progress in Marketing Research”, Journal of Marketing, vol. 3, no. 3 (Jan. 1939), pp. 291-292, accessed on JSTOR Apr. 2025)
To this end, the map shows the distribution of five “classes” of markets across the American landscape: From Class A, with retail sales over $25,000,000, to Class E, with retail sales under $2,500,000. Each market class is assigned a distinct color and/or symbol, so the distribution of each can be readily visualized on the map.
The map’s main point is that advertisers must understand that, while the United States was (and remains) vast, retail sales were concentrated in a relatively tiny portion of the landscape: According to the table at lower left, the study found that 1901 “urban markets” occupying only 2 ½% of the United States’ land area held 65% of the population and a whopping 86% of all retail sales. Indeed the concentration is even more intense than those figures would suggest: Of those 1901 urban markets, a mere 131 accounted for more than 63% of all retail sales.
The point of all this was to enable a more efficient allocation of outdoor advertising budgets, providing information that helped advertisers target roads and road networks where their billboards were likely to be seen by the largest possible number of automobile travelers.
“This study is designed to be used as the basis of a selective marketing program – to establish sales quotas and allocate advertising appropriations – to correlate costs and to plan test campaigns – in accordance with market potentials.” (table at lower left of map)
A rare survival, possibly unique, of an era when the proliferation of data, the growth of national consumer-products firms, and the spread of automobile ownership were transforming the methods of marketing.
References
Not in OCLC, and as of April 2025 a Google search turns up no other examples.
Inventory ID:
An innovative Depression-era map of American retail markets
[After John E. Brennan] / American Map Company, URBAN MARKETS AND RETAIL SALES. New York: Outdoor Advertising Incorporated, ca 1939.
$3,000.00
In stock
42”h x 61 ½”w at neat line plus margins. Backed with cloth and mounted on dowels, as issued. Minor creasing and soiling, small chip lifting in title, small hole in western Pennsylvania. Still, about very good for such a large wall map.
A very rare thematic map highlighting the major consumer markets of the United States, reflecting the revolutionary impact of the automobile on marketing, and nice evidence of the American economy’s continued capacity for innovation even in the depths of the Depression.
Background
Prior to the advent of the mass-marketed automobile, advertising was primarily a matter of placement of ads in newspapers and magazines, and of poster displays in public spaces. With the spread of automotive transportation into the American middle class, an entirely new advertising medium emerged: the roadside billboard. Large, designed to present simple messages in the most eye-catching manner possible, and by nature intrusive on the visual fields of drivers and passengers alike, billboards quickly spread over the American landscape.
Like most emerging industries, the billboard marketplace seems to have been highly fragmented, highly local, and—I assume—highly inefficient. To address this issue, in 1931 players in the industry banded together to form Outdoor Advertising Incorporated (OAI), which seems to have been an agency for marketing billboards to large companies and the ad agencies representing them.
“Practically the entire industry has joined together so that Outdoor Advertising campaigns can be properly planned and presented to America’s industries. The result is an organization to be known as Outdoor Advertising Incorporated. This company will act as the industry’s representative. It is their best effort to improve the merchandising possibilities of their medium.” (Harold Eves, “The “Outdoor” Industry Looks Ahead”, Advertising Outdoors, vol. 2 no. 7 (July 1931), p. 5)
Best as I can tell, OAI was a for-profit venture providing the billboard industry with a wide range of marketing, design, production, research, and consulting services. (“Outdoor Advertising Incorporated and How It Will Operate”, Advertising Outdoors, vol. 2 no. 7 (July 1931), pp. 11-13, 45-46, accessed online Apr. 2025)
The map
Around 1939 the organization published this massive map to illustrate the key findings of an OAI study, also titled “Urban Markets and Retail Sales”.
“A most elaborate study has recently been completed by [OAI] under the direction of John E. Brennan [a researcher specializing in assessing the effectiveness of billboard advertising, fl. 1947-1980]. It is a study of “Urban Markets and Retail Sales” and represents a new approach to market evaluation. This study presents retail sales figures drawn from the Census of Retail Distribution of the U.S. Department of Commerce, 1935 edition, grouped according to “masses of people” rather than any particular political unit…. The purpose of the study is to answer the demand for a more flexible and more practical method of market appraisal as an aid to selective and profitable selling. One interesting feature of the maps presented is the fact that they are plotted against the highway pattern of the state.” (Ferdinand C. Wheeler, “Progress in Marketing Research”, Journal of Marketing, vol. 3, no. 3 (Jan. 1939), pp. 291-292, accessed on JSTOR Apr. 2025)
To this end, the map shows the distribution of five “classes” of markets across the American landscape: From Class A, with retail sales over $25,000,000, to Class E, with retail sales under $2,500,000. Each market class is assigned a distinct color and/or symbol, so the distribution of each can be readily visualized on the map.
The map’s main point is that advertisers must understand that, while the United States was (and remains) vast, retail sales were concentrated in a relatively tiny portion of the landscape: According to the table at lower left, the study found that 1901 “urban markets” occupying only 2 ½% of the United States’ land area held 65% of the population and a whopping 86% of all retail sales. Indeed the concentration is even more intense than those figures would suggest: Of those 1901 urban markets, a mere 131 accounted for more than 63% of all retail sales.
The point of all this was to enable a more efficient allocation of outdoor advertising budgets, providing information that helped advertisers target roads and road networks where their billboards were likely to be seen by the largest possible number of automobile travelers.
“This study is designed to be used as the basis of a selective marketing program – to establish sales quotas and allocate advertising appropriations – to correlate costs and to plan test campaigns – in accordance with market potentials.” (table at lower left of map)
A rare survival, possibly unique, of an era when the proliferation of data, the growth of national consumer-products firms, and the spread of automobile ownership were transforming the methods of marketing.
References
Not in OCLC, and as of April 2025 a Google search turns up no other examples.
Additional information
| year published | 1939 |
|---|---|
| author(s) | Brennan, John E. |
| publisher | Outdoor Advertising Incorporated |
| associations | Brennan, John E., Outdoor Advertising Incorporated |








